[Activities][Debate contest] Winner result! Robotic driver vs Human driver
End Time: 2016-10-31 10:42
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Related threadsSignatureFlyme, go global! |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Edited by sathishkumar at 2016-09-28 12:16
Robotic driving technology will be better than human driving , because robots will, have better visual , good hearing power and one more main reason is it wont have any alcohols  and using various sensors accidents can be controlled easily , thats why i prefer robotic driving than human one.dominos deliverys food by robots
| |
RateExperience +5Prestige 0Gold +42           |
|
|
this is a very difficult question. There are reasons to support the robot driver and there are reasons why I would not support it. Alcoholic state of the problem with the most traffic accidents. What scares me whether the robot can make decisions as a man. Does the robot driver who drives a truck accidentally noticed a car with people can decide to turn off the street and save other people from certain death shock cars and trucks. The question is whether the artificial intelligence so advanced that it can take decisions. Maybe not informed
| |
RateExperience 0Prestige 0Gold +3  |
|
|
I would choose a human driver. There are some reasons for this choice: Failure of technology 
It is very much possible that the Robotic car could develop some technical snag of connected parts within car like onboard cameras or sensors. In such a scenario when even one part fails to respond, it could be quite a risky affair for the passengers of the vehicle. Possibility of a Virus or hacking
Since the car is always required to be connected to the internet for GPS, navigation etc., it is quite possible that the car's system and onboard computers could get a computer virus and lead to a malfunction of the robotics. Some hackers might even try to hack into the cars onboard computers and could even compromise with the safety of the passengers especially if he is an influential person like for eg. President of a Country. Human intelligence under poor road conditions
Humans could better judge certain situations especially on Indian road conditions like potholes and help avoid them and drive safely through them. The driverless cars might not be well designed to handle such bad road conditions. Stray animals
On Indian (and many other developing countries) roads we often see a lot of stray animals like stray dogs or stray cattle. Sometimes these stray dogs or cats suddenly run in front of the vehicle when they are playing around or fight with other animals. Under such a scene if the car is at a high speed the driverless car might not be able to judge the situation and might lead to either the animal or the passengers inside to get hurt. Humans (who face such situations often) would be able to tackle this better. Could lead to increase in crimes
Crimes like kidnapping or murders could increase as the onboard computers and cars systems could be hacked via internet and the technology could be misused for something like murder through accidents or kidnapping by hacking and controlling the car from a remote location Internet speeds and Network drops
A driverless car would require to be connected to internet continuously but in a country like India where the internet speeds are not very fast and network drops are very common the safety of passengers could be at a risk. Imagine you are at high speeds in such a car and suddenly there is a network drop and the robotics might not know of an upcoming curve on the road or oncoming traffic. Sounds risky right? Hence it is always better to trust yourself (humans) rather then to trust technology with the safety of yourself and your loved ones...  | |
RateExperience +1Prestige 0Gold +41          |
|
|
"Robotic" drivers (AI) will be great option only if all cars would be like this. Untill there will be even 1 human driver, there won't be safer. What is more, autonomous cars must be connected to each other, so they will be notified about action of any of them.
A lot of time will pass till solutions like this would replace human drivers  | |
RateExperience 0Prestige 0Gold +6  |
|
|
Edited by arka1004 at 2016-09-24 15:25
Support human driver because: 1.Millions of unregistered vehicles,poor quality roads,rapid illegal urbanization also lots of issue in India.So as per India Robotic drivers never a practical idea India.  2.Unemployment a mojor issue in India so without solve never want that drivers loss their driving-related jobs.  3.malfunction or system crash by any chance software crash then harmful for all. 4.Customer concern about the safety of Robotic drivers,as previously occurred with operatorless elevators.  5.Interpreting problem robotic driver weak to interpreting body language from traffic polices and others. 6.If any complex situations arise when need manual drving which inexperience. So in my view Human drivers more more better also reliable than technology.
| |
RateExperience 0Prestige 0Gold +16  |
|
|
Robotic drivers
Because humans of today are very impatient and more often break traffic rules which leads to accidents. The robotic drivers are created after many years of research and development and so would help reduce and even eliminate such accidents due to human negligence by a great extent and traffic rules too won't be violated. The roads would be safe for even the pedestrians. Another important to note is in case of emergency response services as autonomous robotic drivers would help to respond emergency situations and help to reach the needful faster in case of fire, police or ambulance facilities required. Humans lead to lot of negligence in such cases due to bad driving habits of other drivers. | |
RateExperience 0Prestige 0Gold +30  |
|
|
Hi, It's great idea to have robotic drivers as people are so busy and too much stressed at times to drive properly and deliver driving on different levels of life. So after rigorous testing process robot can be adapted gradually in our cars for driving.. Another aspect is diminishing population in world and better managed capabilities to drive the car properly by robots. And we must adapt situations as with times advances. And very lastly the world with terrorists not safe for human drivers as their first targets are to procure car for their activities.... And we can save many lives.
| |
RateExperience 0Prestige 0Gold +2  |
|
|
I would rather choose a Human driver instead of a Robotic one. This is a vast topic and I would like to sum up in short.
1. Humans can interpret and handle an accident situation better than an Robot and more faster than it. 2. Since robots are a machine, they can malfunction and can be penetrated by hackers. 3. There can be communication issues too with your robot driver. 4. Recently there was a few crash incidents that happened with Google's Self-Driving car. Which means that its not completely reliable. 5. It may be possible that the robots may not identify the peds or the surroundings properly in different weather conditions, thus leading to a mishap. | |
RateExperience +5Prestige 0Gold +29   |
|
|
Robotics drivers are not stable.Google is making smart driving accident,other firms are doing the smart drive crash.
The risk of hacking,more than enough to get the car navigation. human drives use better,As long as they do so speed (speed )I don't trust anything that is not stable,i use myself better.The pleasure of working(drive) there.. Human Driver Best  | |
RateExperience 0Prestige 0Gold +10 |
|
65